From Our Founder: scaffolding around a building
October 14, 2026

How Great Managers Turn Insight Into Habit

In short

I've watched great workshops fade by the next week. Here's how I use "Scaffolding" to turn personality insight into habits that stick, one piece at a time.

Anyone who has been through a great team workshop knows the feeling that follows. For a week or two, everyone is a little more patient with each other, someone jokes about their Extraversion score in a meeting, and the team seems to have a new shared language. Then the calendar fills back up, the deadlines return, and the old patterns quietly settle back in.

The insight simply had nowhere to live. Knowing that a colleague does their best thinking after a meeting doesn't change anything until the meeting itself changes, and that's the gap my book, Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team, calls "Scaffolding."

Why "Try Harder" Never Works

In the book, "Scaffolding" means the systems, processes, habits, and agreements you put around natural tendencies so they stop getting in the way of good work, while leaving everyone's personality exactly as it is. Your traits are relatively stable, but the strategies you build around them are far more flexible, and that's where all the room for improvement lives.

That's also why the most useful changes are aimed at behavior rather than personality. "I need to be more detail-oriented" is a wish. "I'll use a checklist before anything goes to a client" is a plan. The same is true for teams: "we need to communicate better" rarely changes anything, while "we send the agenda a day ahead" changes something every single week.

I chose the word on purpose. Your team is the one doing the building: the product, the client relationships, the company itself. As a manager, your job is to put up the "Scaffolding" around them, the supports that let each person reach the work and do it well. And unlike scaffolding on a construction site, yours doesn't have to come down once the building is finished. A structure your team keeps using for years is simply a structure that works.

Your Meetings Were Built for One Kind of Person

Most meetings are designed, without anyone meaning to, for the person who thinks fast, speaks easily, and is comfortable disagreeing in real time. Everyone else is either adapting or going quiet, and the team loses whatever they would have said.

A few small structures make a meeting work for a much wider range of people. Send the agenda ahead, with the actual questions to be decided, so the people who like to think first arrive with a point ready. Open with a few minutes of quiet writing before the discussion starts. Before moving on, ask to hear from anyone who hasn't weighed in. And separate the part of the meeting where ideas range freely from the part where a decision gets made, so the people who love to explore and the people who want to close both know where they are. None of this slows a meeting down much, and it means the decision draws on the thinking of the whole room, including the people who process quietly.

The One-on-One Question Most Managers Never Ask

The one-on-one is the single best structure a manager has, because it's the one meeting designed for one specific person. It works best when each one is shaped around the person in it.

A standing question chosen for the person in front of you does most of the work. For someone toward the higher end of Agreeableness, it might be "What's one thing you've been hesitant to bring up?" For someone toward the higher end of Neuroticism, "What's on your risk list right now?" For someone toward the lower end of Extraversion, "Was there anything you were thinking in this week's meetings that didn't get said?" But the most useful question of all is simpler: "What do you need from these conversations that you're not getting?" Most people have never been asked, and the answer usually tells you exactly how to manage them.

"Can You Take This On?" Is the Wrong Question

Defaults shape how people take on work, which means "Can you take this on?" gets very different answers that have little to do with actual capacity. People toward the higher end of Agreeableness tend to say yes, people toward the higher end of Conscientiousness say yes and then work longer hours to deliver at the same standard, and people toward the higher end of Openness may say yes because the new project sounds more interesting than the current one.

A better question is "Which existing priority should move?" Make it the standard question whenever you add work to anyone's plate, ask it yourself instead of waiting for them to, and check in on workload regularly rather than only when someone looks overwhelmed. The people most likely to burn out are often the least likely to say so.

How to Make Disagreement Part of the Plan

Some teams don't have a friction problem at all (I wrote about the many flavors of groupthink in Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team). Meetings are pleasant, decisions come quickly, and nobody pushes back very hard, which can be a sign of a healthy team or a sign that everyone is seeing the same thing. A little structure makes sure you find out which.

Two of my favorite tools are simple. The first is a devil's advocate whose job is to argue the other side of a big decision in good faith, and the role should rotate, so it never becomes one person's permanent identity. The second is a pre-mortem: before a major project starts, ask everyone to imagine it's a year from now and the project has failed, then have each person write down, on their own, the most likely reason why. Concerns that would have sounded like negativity in the middle of a launch become valuable input when the team asked for them up front.

Build One Piece at a Time

The most common mistake with "Scaffolding" is building too much of it at once. You come out of a workshop motivated, redesign everything on a Sunday afternoon, and by the following Wednesday the new system has quietly collapsed under its own weight.

So pick one recurring friction point, the one that shows up most often and costs the most, and build one small structure for it. Attach it to something that already happens, like the Monday team meeting, and make it specific enough to check. Then give it a few weeks and ask the people it was meant to help whether they've noticed a difference. If it works, keep it and choose the next one. That's how a workshop's insights stop fading and start compounding.

"Scaffolding" works best for friction between people. In the next post, When Your Job Keeps Asking You to Be Someone Else, I'll look at a different kind of friction: what happens when your role keeps asking you to work against your natural defaults, day after day, and how to tell when better structure will fix it and when it might be time for a different role.

If you're curious where you and your team land, start with the free test. It takes about 10 minutes, and you'll see your five trait scores the moment you finish.

Christin Camacho is the founder and CEO of Big 5 at Work and the author of Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team.

Big 5 at Work logo

Schedule a team-building workshop
with a lasting impact