From Our Founder: seedling in soil
October 8, 2026

Can People Really Change? What I Learned From the Science of Personality

In short

I used to wonder whether people can really change. The science says your personality is your default, not your destiny, and here's why that matters at work.

If you grew up with a brother or a sister, you've already seen one of the most persuasive personality studies ever run. Same parents, same house, same rules about bedtime and vegetables, and yet one of you kept a color-coded homework planner while the other discovered the assignment on the bus.

That question of where those differences come from follows all of us into work, where it gets more expensive. When a colleague's way of working drives you up the wall, can they change? When your own tendencies keep tripping you up, can you? Most of us reach for one of two easy answers: "that's just how they are," or "they could be different if they really tried." When I started reading the research, I was surprised to find that it supports neither one, and what it does support turned out to be far more useful.

Where Your Personality Really Comes From

Here's the number that gets quoted most often. When researchers pooled 45 studies covering more than 113,000 people, genetic differences accounted for roughly 40 percent of the differences between people on the Big Five traits. That's a meaningful number, and it's also one of the most misunderstood, because it describes differences across a population, never the makeup of any one person. Nobody's Extraversion is 40 percent genes and 60 percent everything else.

The largest personality genetics study ever conducted, published in Nature in 2026 and drawing on more than a million people, added two findings I find reassuring. Personality is shaped by thousands of tiny genetic influences rather than a single "anxiety gene" or "life of the party" gene, and even all of them combined can't predict what any one person will do. If the DNA of a million people can't forecast one person's behavior, no single score or label can either, which is exactly why I believe a personality assessment should start a conversation and never be used to hire, promote, or rank anyone.

Seeds and Soil

So if genes account for something like 40 percent of the differences, you might assume upbringing accounts for most of the rest. This is where the research surprises almost everyone. Growing up in the same house does remarkably little to make siblings alike on these five traits, because the "same" upbringing is rarely the same: siblings have different friends, different teachers, and different places in the family.

And experience keeps shaping us long after childhood. One long-running study of twins found that by midlife, life experience had become a steady part of what keeps personality consistent, most likely because people choose environments that fit them and are then shaped by those environments in return. Geneticists often explain this with seeds and soil. Every plant needs both to grow, so you can never split one plant's height into "40 percent seed, 60 percent soil." But plant seeds from different packets in the same even soil, and the differences between the plants will mostly reflect the seeds; plant identical seeds in patchy soil, and the differences will mostly reflect the soil.

For most adults, work is a big part of the soil. The roles we take, the teams we join, and the routines our jobs require become part of what keeps our personalities steady over time, which gives managers and companies more influence than they might realize.

Stable, but Never Finished

Personality settles as we get older, but it never stops moving. Research following more than 21,000 pairs of siblings from infancy into old age found that people's relative standing on each trait becomes steadily more consistent through young adulthood, and many people become a bit more organized, agreeable, and emotionally steady with age.

Think of the class photo at a twenty-year reunion. Everyone has changed, and the class clown now runs a credit union, but the tallest kids from the original photo are still mostly among the tallest people in the room. For managers, that has a practical upshot: a first impression of a 23-year-old is a snapshot, while a midcareer colleague's tendencies are usually steady enough to build roles and routines around.

Know Your Default, Change Your Destiny

This is the idea that changed how I think about personality, and it's the heart of my book, Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team. Personality researcher Colin DeYoung separates traits, which are relatively stable, from the goals, habits, and strategies each of us builds around them, which can change far more quickly. Your traits are your default. They're where you start, and where you drift back to under pressure. The strategies you build are how you go further.

The best analogy I know is eyeglasses. Nobody expects someone with poor eyesight to fix their eyes through effort, and nobody calls them lazy for not seeing the whiteboard. They get glasses, and then they see perfectly well. Telling someone toward the lower end of Conscientiousness to "be more detail-oriented" asks them to squint harder all day, indefinitely. Helping them build a checklist gives them glasses.

That's why I encourage everyone to understand their default first. You can't build good strategies around tendencies you haven't identified, and the hardest personality to see clearly is usually your own, because from the inside it doesn't feel like a personality at all. It feels like the obvious way to do things.

In the next post, Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team, I'll look at what happens when a team is made up of very different defaults, and why that mix is one of its biggest advantages.

If you're curious where you land, start with the free test. It takes about 10 minutes, and you'll see your five trait scores the moment you finish.

Christin Camacho is the founder and CEO of Big 5 at Work and the author of Why You Need Neurotic People on Your Team.

Big 5 at Work logo

Schedule a team-building workshop
with a lasting impact